A lawsuit filed Tuesday accuses Rabbi Daniel Greer — who revived a
declining neighborhood and has publicly crusaded against gay rights,
prostitution, and coed university dorms — of repeatedly raping and
molesting students at his yeshiva at Elm and Norton streets.
Greer, through his attorney, denied the allegations.
An attorney for Eliyahu Mirlis, the alleged victim, filed the lawsuit in U.S. District Court in New Haven.
The suit names Greer and the two schools he founded and runs — the Gan School, a mixed-gender elementary school; and the Yeshiva of New Haven, a boarding high school for boys — as defendants.
The
case has already started fraying a tight-knit religious family
community centered around the yeshiva, in the former Roger Sherman
School building at 765 Elm St. Through a series of corporations, Greer
and his family bought, renovated, and have since rented out some four
dozen multi-family homes on surrounding blocks, many of them notable for
their eight-foot-high stockade fences. Passionate minyanim, or
prayer services, occur daily in the morning and evening on the second
floor of the school, which has doubled as a small neighborhood
synagogue. Enrollment at the yeshiva dwindled to close to zero in recent
months as word about the allegations spread through the Orthodox Jewish
community. Officials resigned from the boards of the schools and the
real estate corporations.
The yeshiva building at 765 Elm.
The fates of both the two schools and the portfolio of around 125
apartments in the neighborhood remain unclear in the wake of the
lawsuit, which seeks unspecified compensatory and punitive damages.
Mirlis attended the yeshiva and lived in Greer-owned housing from 2001 to 2005.
Greer,
who is 75 today and was in his 60s at the time, “repeatedly and
continuously sexually abused, exploited, and assaulted” Mirlis during
his sophomore through senior years, when he was 15 to 17 years old,
according to the complaint. It describes the abuse as “acts of sex ...
including forced fellatio, anal sex, fondling and masturbation.”
“Rabbi Greer frequently gave Eli alcohol at the time he raped and assaulted his child victim,” the complaint charges.
“Rabbi
Greer showed Eli pornographic films. Rabbi Greer anally raped,
sodomized and in other ways sexually assaulted, abused and molested Eli
dozens and dozens of times, with each incident lasting on average from
one to four hours, and sometimes all night.
“Rabbi Greer raped,
sodomized and sexually assaulted, abused and molested Eli on school
property, in the bedroom of the Rabbi’s private residence, at motels in
Branford, Connecticut and Paoli and Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, on land
in Hamden, Connecticut, and at rental properties in New Haven owned and
managed by Yeshiva of New Haven, Inc., The Gan School, Inc., and other
non-stock Connecticut corporations of which Rabbi Greer was the
President, Director and Treasurer, including properties located at 777
Elm Street, 203, 209 and 211 Norton Street, 139 West Park Avenue, 439
Edgewood Avenue, and 193 Maple Street.”
The school’s “senior
officials” “knew and/or should have known that the Rabbi was raping,
sodomizing and sexually assaulting, abusing and molesting the minor boy;
and they did nothing to stop it,” the complaint charges. “At all
relevant times, administrators and officials of The School failed to
safeguard the keys to the rental properties, providing Rabbi Greer with
multiple places where he could rape and assault his child victim at his
leisure without fear of being discovered or stopped.” The complaint
specifically cites an unnamed assistant principal as having had
knowledge of the abuse but not taking action.
The suit further
charges that “during the years prior to his sexual molestation of Eli,
Greer sexually abused, molested and exploited at least one other minor
boy in the care and custody of The School.”
State law — Conn. Gen.
Stat. Sec. 17-38a — required school officials to notify authorities
about suspicions about child abuse taking place, the complaint
continues.
“The School employed a pedophile, and allowed that
pedophile free reign to gratify his perverse sexual desires by molesting
a young vulnerable boy in The School’s care and custody,” the state
alleges.
The suit claims that the abuse has left Mirlis with
“severe emotional distress, humiliation, embarrassment, pain and
anguish, anxiety, panic, sexual dysfunction, PTSD, depression,
hyper-vigilance, shame, and low self-esteem” that have “permanently
damaged” his “educational and career prospects.” The suit does not
specify an amount sought for damages beyond Mirlis, who is 28
years old and lives in New Jersey, is represented in the suit by
attorney Antonio Ponvert III of the Bridgeport firm Koskoff Koskoff
& Bieder.
Rabbi Greer, who has maintained a confident position
of innocence amid the allegations, referred a request for comment for
this article to his attorney, William Ward.
Ward denied the accusations on Greer’s behalf in a conversation late Tuesday morning with the Independent.
“It
only takes a moment to make allegations with despicable indifference to
the consequences of the damage they would cause to my client, his
family, and his reputation that he spent a lifetime building in his
community. This is a difficult time for my client and his family. But I
would remind the public to ask for evidence before rushing to judgment,
as my client is now burdened with the task of proving something did not
happen 14 years ago, as alleged by Mr. Mirlis,” Ward said.
“Ask
yourself why Mr. Mirlis would wait 14 years. Ask yourself why Mr.
Mirlis, well into his adulthood, repeatedly honored the man he now
accuses. Ask yourself why Mr. Mirlis, an Orthodox Jew, would not seek
redress form a rabbinical arbitration court. Ask yourself why Mr.
Mirlis’s first stop was his lawyer’s office to seek money. And finally
ask yourself why his attorney would issue a press release.”
Attorney
Ponvert responded that victims of childhood sexual abuse often take
years to come to grips with what happened to them and come forward with
allegations, and in the meantime may maintain contact with their
abusers. He said his client felt his best chance for justice lay in the
civil courts.
“The waiting, first of all, is a well-known
consequence of the infliction of childhood sexual abuse. If children
were able to understand what was happening to them when they were being
groomed and manipulated by an adult for that adult’s sexual
gratification—if the children understood that at the time most of these
would be reported when they happened. That doesn’t usually happen,
because adults who sexually molest children tend to be very persuasive,
very calculated, and very adept at choosing vulnerable victims who do
not have the ability to get out of the relationship,” Ponvert said.
He
said that one reason Mirlis “waited 14 years was because of the power
that this man held over him. This your rabbi. This is the principal of
your school. This is a 60-year-old man who is showing affection to you
you’re not getting anywhere else in the world. He’s chosen you. You now
have this person who has chosen you for this special relationship which
he is telling you every day that it occurs is healthy and good. The time
lag between that and the reporting is evidence of how good a molester
and manipulator that Greer is.”
Police Will Look Into Case
The
statute of limitations to file a federal suit is 30 years from the time
of the alleged incident. The same is true for the state of Connecticut
to pursue criminal charges, under the Connecticut General Statutes section 54-193a.
Ponvert
said Mirlis has not sought to pursue criminal charges. But if the
police or state’s attorney decide to pursue an investigation, “obviously
my client will fully cooperate,” Ponvert said.
Upon the
announcement of this information, the department will be reaching out to
the plaintiff’s attorney,” Police Chief Dean Esserman told the
Independent Tuesday.
Ponvert said his client chose a lawsuit
rather than a criminal complaint to pursue his complaint because “he has
the ability to attempt to control getting justice in the civil arena.”
The
assistant principal named in the lawsuit did not return calls for this
story. He has retained a local attorney, who, according to a secretary,
is out of the country and unavailable. The assistant stepped down from
his job in 2015.
Neighborhood Builder
Since Daniel Greer returned to New Haven in the 1970s, he has fought to
create and preserve his visions of both urban neighborhoods and sexual
morality.
Greer first came to New Haven to attend Yale Law School,
where he roomed with future California governor and presidential
candidate Jerry Brown. He then moved to New York City, where he served
as an official (deputy commissioner for ports and terminals) for Mayor
John Lindsay. He also led a successful campaign to force the United States to pressure the Soviet Union into allowing Jewish “refuseniks” to emigrate here and start new, freer lives.
Back
in New Haven, he set out to create a walkable, safe enclave in the
Edgewood neighborhood where he and his wife could create an Orthodox
school for their children and other Jewish children.
His success
in stabilizing a declining neighborhood has inspired clergy from other
faiths to try the same approach in other parts of town plagued by
absentee slumlords.
From the start, Greer understood the need for political and community ties to succeed with his mission. He cultivated corporate donors,
some of whom could contribute to his group’s not-for-profit real-estate
efforts through the state Neighborhood Assistance Act. The annual yeshiva community dinner has honored leaders in the broader community and drawn political leaders from throughout the state.
He
served on city boards and commissions. He played an important role as a
member of the Board of Police Commissioners in hearings that exposed
massive illegal NHPD wiretapping of government dissidents and political
opponents. He later served on the Redevelopment Authority board as well.
Greer
was also outspoken about sexual mores. He railed to a crowd against the
evils of homosexuality and gay marriage at a rally at the state
capitol. Gan members also testified in New Haven against a domestic
partnership law.
Jew vs. Jew
When Greer’s daughter
attended Yale, he led a legal fight in 1997 against co-ed dorms, which
he depicted as dens of immorality. He didn’t prevail in court. But he
embarrassed Yale with national news coverage of the “Yale 5” case, including a lengthy New York Times Magazine story that author Samuel Freedman expanded into a central part of his book Jew vs. Jew.
In
recent weeks, Greer has threatened legal action against a local
blogger, Lawrence Dressler, who has published accusations against Greer
on his site.
Ward, Greer’s attorney, sent an April 18 cease-and-desist letter to Dressler, who used to pray at the yeshiva minyan and launched the blog after serving 20 months in prison on a mortgage fraud-related charge.
The letter requested that Dressler publish a “retraction and apology”
for what he’d written about Greer and the yeshiva, and refrain from
making “any further false statements about Rabbi Greer and the Yeshiva
of New Haven.” He also called the accusations “defamatory.”
“These
statements have caused great distress to my client and have damaged the
reputation of the Yeshiva and Rabbi Greer,” Ward wrote.
Joseph
Merly, an attorney in the New Haven law firm headed by John R. Williams,
responded on April 20 with a letter written on Dressler’s behalf. “Mr.
Dressler has no intention of retracting any statements ...” the letter
informed Ward. “The statements which Mr. Dressler made are completely
true and accurate and as you know, truth is the best defense to a claim
of defamation. In fact, Mr. Dressler intends to expand his efforts to
bring forth victims of your clients and publishing their stories and to
continue alerting the community to your clients’ crimes.”
Rabbi Ari Hart: Why Jewish leaders want abusers to pay
Rabbi Ari Hart --- NEW YORK DAILY NEWS
Fix the law
The famous joke goes: two Jews, three opinions. Yet last week, more
than 100 Jewish leaders from across the religious and ideological
divides came together, with one voice, to declare their support for
statute of limitations reform for child abuse victims in New York State.
Why statute of limitations reform, and why are Jewish leaders lining up
behind this bill? Because it’s our obligation as men and women of faith
who purport to help people heal. And it is, I believe, our obligation
as followers of the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.
After decades of denial, cover-ups and darkness, the light is finally
shining on the scourge of child sexual abuse. Today, we better
understand the high rate of its prevalence, the lasting and far-reaching
damage caused by abusers, and the extreme difficulty survivors face in
coming forward and seek justice. Tragically, New York State’s regressive
laws prevent many victims from getting the justice they deserve and
from stopping abusers from causing more harm.
While mental health experts have shown that it can take decades for a
victim of child sexual abuse to overcome the fear, shame and trauma of
abuse and come forward, our statutes allow someone to pursue criminal or
civil justice only until the victim turns 23.
As a rabbi, I have met people in their 40s, 50s and 60s who are only
now coming to grips with what happened to them as children, and only now
able to come forward. New York law fails these victims by giving a
victim only five years from the time they enter adulthood to act.
New York state has been ranked among the very worst, alongside
Mississippi, Alabama and Michigan, for how the courts and criminal
justice system treat survivors of child sex abuse.
We take this stand not only as New Yorkers and Americans, but as Jews.
Judaism is a religion as concerned with what happens in the courthouse
with what happens in the synagogue. Fairness, justice and protecting the
vulnerable are hallmarks of the Torah — calls made in our sacred texts
over and over again.
In addition, Jewish law does not recognize the concept of a statute of
limitations: If a wrong was committed, if someone has harmed, they
always have the right to seek justice.
It is also long past time that Jewish leaders came to grips with the
fact that rather being a source of healing for victims of child sexual
abuse, sometimes our religious institutions and leaders have been part
of the problem. Too often, they have discouraged victims from going to
the police. Too often, they have been enablers or even perpetrators of
abuse.
Shamefully, it has been religious groups that have played the most
prominent role in blocking the passage of statute of limitations reform
in New York State until now. Why? Enacting this legislation puts many
institutions, religious and otherwise, at financial risk for actions
that protected abusers, ignored abuse claims or directly perpetrated
abuse in the past.
But if the passage of statute of limitations reform means that
religious institutions will have to bear the burden of increased
financial risk, that is a burden we must find a way to bear. Have
victims with profound emotional scars, shattered faith and more not paid
a price beyond any dollar amount?
We must ask ourselves: to which bottom line are we accountable? Those of profits, of those of the prophets?
The Torah teaches: Tzedek tzedek tirdof, justice justice you shall
pursue. Though we cannot undo the pain that was done, often under our
own auspices, faith leaders can stand with victims of child sexual abuse
in their quest for justice. Faith leaders can fulfill our mandate to be
relentless pursuers of justice by calling on Albany to pass the Child
Victim’s Act.
Hart is an Orthodox rabbi.
VERY GRAPHIC VIDEO OF RABBI IN SATMAR COMMUNITY MOLESTING A CHILD: WARNING!!!
Chaim Levin, of the anti-abuse group Kol Voz, wants "to give people the power of the court to hold their abuser accountable.”
A coalition of more than 130 Jewish leaders now back the Child Victims
Act which would eliminate the statute of limitation in New York —
allowing countless child sex abuse victims to seek justice as adults
The show of support on Thursday comes just days before advocates of the
bill plan a two-day lobbying effort in Albany to win passage of the
long-languishing legislation.
“After decades of denial, coverups and darkness across New York State,
light is finally being shone on the scourge of child sexual abuse,” read
the petition signed by scores of high-profile leaders.
“The lasting and far-reaching damage caused by abusers is intolerable,
and it is incumbent upon all the citizens of New York State to work to
reduce it.”
The writers also acknowledged the role played by "religious institutions" in blocking the legislation in past years.
Former
Manhattan Borough President Ruth Messinger (seen with Cardinal Donald
Wuerl, archbishop of Washington, in September 2015) is among those
signing the petition.
Agudath Israel of America, an umbrella group representing Orthodox
Jewish groups, joined the Catholic Church in successfully lobbying to
derail the proposed law.
The bill was first introduced a decade ago by state Assemblywoman
Margaret Markey (D-Queens), and has failed to pass in four previous
tries.
Nine Jewish organizations are planning a trip to Albany to add their
voices to the chorus supporting a change in the law on Tuesday and
Wednesday.
“The most exciting thing about it is the range of voices — from right
wing Orthodox to left-wing, secular Jews and everything in between,”
Rabbi Ari Hart said.
Queens Assemblywoman Margaret Markey (second from left) introduced the bill a decade ago.
Among those signing the petition were close to 100 rabbis and former Manhattan Borough President Ruth Messinger.
“We need to demonstrate that some large groups who oppose this bill
don’t speak for everyone,” said Chaim Levin, 26, of the group Kol Voz — a
new global organization attempting to combat abuse in Jewish
communities.
“We want to show our lawmakers that the Agudath does not represent
everyone,” the Crown Height resident continued. “One of the most
important parts of dealing with abuse is to give people the power of the
court to hold their abuser accountable.”
Current New York law gives the victims up until the age of 23 to seek
recourse in the court system — although many victims need years to deal
with their abuse, and miss the deadline.
Fugitive Rabbi Accused of Sex Crimes Wants 'Guarantees' if Extradited to Israel
Lawyer for Rabbi Eliezer Berland, 78, gets into shouting match with magistrate.
JOHANNESBURG – The attorney for Israeli Rabbi Eliezer Berland, a fugitive accused of serial sex crimes, closed his case at the rabbi’s bail hearing in the Randburg Magistrate’s Court on Tuesday, mounting an impassioned plea that the rabbi be given bail, especially since it is Passover.
Lawyer Themba Langa said the rabbi was a man of elevated spirituality and probity, and “in the normal course of events” would have returned to Israel to deal with the allegations of sexual assault made against him by followers.
“But,” said Langa, “I have been instructed by the rabbi that he needs certain guarantees before he can return to Israel. The Israeli state has moved against certain people. We all know the name Ariel Sharon, who was injected and put into a four-year [sic] coma. And the state has also targeted a Rabbi Pinto …”
Langa did not offer any further explanation. But it is understood he was referring to the late prime minister Sharon, who died of natural causes, and to Rabbi Yoshiyahu Yosef Pinto of Mosdot Shuva Israel, who last year was found guilty of bribery, attempted bribery, obstruction of justice and started his prison sentence on February 16.
Berland, 78, one of the leaders of the Bratslav Hasidic movement in Israel and considered a holy man by his followers, has been on the run since 2012 when allegations were made by female followers in Israel that he had variously raped or sexually harassed them. Berland has managed to live under the noses of authorities from Morocco to the Netherlands and Zimbabwe. In South Africa, prior to his arrest on April 7, he had been staying at hotels and golf estates. He is followed by about 40 families, to whom he is a spiritual guru.
The day’s business began with Langa saying that South African authorities had botched the extradition process by moving to a bail hearing before a proper inquiry was held into the charges brought against Berland. “This being the case,” said Langa, “keeping him in custody now is therefore irregular. And he should be released.”
Regional Magistrate Pravina Raghunandan, who had earlier in the morning called the legal teams to her chambers to let them know that she herself was “concerned” about whether the court had the authority to hold a bail hearing, clearly took offense at Langa introducing her concern as his own legal argument – and asked when he had discovered that the court process might be flawed and why he had not raised the matter before.
Magistrate: 'Don't point fingers at court!'
This dialogue descended into a shouting match, with Langa apparently losing his temper and Raghunandan telling him not “to point his fingers at the court, not to shout at the court and not to call the court incompetent.” The prosecutor, advocate Nerisha Naidoo, said the decision to hold a bail hearing urgently was as a result of submissions from Langa, who had said some weeks ago that it was “in the interests of justice” to hold a bail hearing for Berland.
Langa then closed his case, telling the court why Berland was not a flight risk. “The rabbi has hired lawyers, attended court, given a home address, surrendered to investigators, and never tried to avoid arrest,” said Langa.
“Moreover,” he continued, “he has an immense worldwide following of about 1.3-million people and is a wonderful spiritual healer. He has been incarcerated for 19 days. In addition, the allegations brought against him seem to have been of the sort that can be easily defended. Clearly some women were uncomfortable but these things happen and can be worked out.”
Naidoo countered that Berland’s Ivory Coast passport was a fake, his Israeli passport belonged to a deceased person, and his entry permit into South Africa had terminated in February; that Berland had repeatedly tried to mislead the court by claiming, for example, that he had applied for political asylum in South Africa, for which there was no proof; that the charges he faced in Israel were in fact serious ones; and that he had given as his permanent address in South Africa a property belonging to someone called Henry Kruger, who had allegedly been an “apartheid-era spy,” and chartered his plane to people who needed to cross borders with a minimum of fuss.
Naidoo said Berland’s situation in South Africa was the same as it had been in the Netherlands. There, she said, he had skipped the country, forfeiting his bail of 50,000 euros. “He could do the same here,” she said. Naidoo said Berland had no followers in Nablus, as claimed, nor was he targeted by Israel – he was merely a fugitive from justice.
Raghunandan then adjourned the proceedings until tomorrow morning – today is Freedom Day, a South African holiday – when she will decide whether Berland can be given bail or must remain in custody. She said that Berland should therefore prepare to go to Johannesburg Prison (known sarcastically as “Sun City” by locals) where he had spent the weekend, including the first three days of Passover.
At this point Langa leapt to his feet and said it was “completely unacceptable” that an “old man who has suffered so much” should be sent to prison where his food has been stolen and three of his followers had been locked up for three hours on Friday night.
Langa spoke for 20 minutes, continually repeating angrily that the state would have “a dead man on its hands” if Berland were returned to Sun City. Despite objections from the prosecution, Raghunandan acquiesced and ordered that Berland be housed in the Randburg police station for the next two nights.
As the judge was leaving the court, Berland surfaced from reading and said to the court that he actually wanted to return to Sun City. “I don’t care about food,” he said, “I want the single cell I have at Sun City so that I can study.”
There was pandemonium in the court and Langa stalked out. An aide of Berland’s, known as Natan, said: “We must do what he wants. We didn’t know that he would prefer to study rather than eat.”
“For then will I turn to the peoples a
pure language that they may all call upon the name of the LORD to serve
Him with one consent. From beyond the rivers of Ethiopia shall they
bring My suppliants even the daughter of My dispersed as Mine offering.”
Zephaniah 3:9-10 (The Israel Bible™)
On
Wednesday afternoon, two of the greatest rabbis of the generation met
and discussed how very close the Messiah is, and how Christians and
Muslims have an important role to play in that process.
Rabbi Moshe Sternbuch,Vice-President of the Rabbinical Court and the Head of the Edah HaChareidis in Jerusalem, paid a rare visit to Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky at his home in Bnei Barak. They
are two of the most prominent Torah figures alive today. Conversations
between such great men have enormous significance and the
Hebrew-language website Kikar Shabbat recorded the dialogue between these two great rabbis.
Rabbi Moshe Sternbuch After warm greetings, the rabbis
began to discuss the problems facing the Jews in this generation. Rabbi
Kanievsky said that troubles were to be expected. “It is the days before
Messiah,” he explained.
Rabbi Sternbuch agreed. “In the End
of Days, those who fear God will despair and their hands will loosen
from fighting God’s war against the sinners, and there will be no one to
rely upon except God,” he said, adding, “We have to bring the Messiah.”
Rabbi Kanievsky answered that the
Messiah should be arriving in the very near future. He quoted the Talmud
(Megillah 17b) again, saying, “In the year after shmittah the Son of David will come.”
Rabbi Kanievsky was referring to a
prediction he had made earlier in the year based on the Talmud. The
shmittah (sabbatical) year comes once every seven years and ended this
year on the holiday of Rosh Hashanah. The year in which Rabbi Kanievsky
predicted the Messiah would come, according to the Talmud, will end next
Rosh Hashana, in September.
“The year after the Shemitta isn’t over,” he added.
Rabbi Sternbuch answered by quoting Jeremiah 8:2,
which reads, “The harvest is past, the summer is ended, and we are not
saved” – implying that according to the Talmud, the Messiah should have
already arrived if it was truly coming in this year.
Rabbi Kanievsky insisted that the
Messiah was indeed coming in this year. He opened the Talmud folio
(Ketubot 112b) that contained the prediction and began to read out loud
to Rabbi Sternbuch. Rabbi Sternbuch considered this and responded with a different source.
“We have an ancient authenticated
hand-written manuscript from the Rambam (a Spanish Torah authority from
the twelfth century), in which he says that before the coming of the
Messiah, the Christians and the Ishmaelites (Arabs) will come to
Israel,” he pointed out.
The manuscript the rabbi referred to is a recent version of the Rambam’sMishnah Torah, recently published with restored sections censored by medieval Christian authorities.
Rabbi Sternbuch’s interpretation of
the Rambam does seem to happening today. The creation of the State of
Israel was a miraculous fulfillment of God’s covenant with Abraham,
restoring the land of Israel to the Jewish people, but it also
benefitted Christians, establishing a bubble of religious freedom in a
region of the world that does not tolerate pluralism. Almost three
million Christians come to Israel every year to visit their holy sites
in a way that is not permitted in regions under Muslim rule, and the
Jewish state is home to a considerable Christian population as well.
Father Gabriel Naddaf Gabriel Naddaf, an Israeli priest of the Greek Orthodox Church, said in an interview with the Algemeiner
that “the Jewish state is the only country in the Middle East where
Christians can practice their faith free from persecution”, noting, “The
Christian community in Israel has more than quadrupled since
independence in 1948, from 34,000 to 158,000 in 2012.”
Though not as positive or as
beneficial as the Christian connection, the Arabs have also multiplied
in the Land of Israel as the Messiah approaches. Before the British
Mandate, Palestine, a neglected corner of the Ottoman Empire, had barely
700,000 people living in the country. As the Jewish population
increased between World War One and World War Two, the Arab population
also increased by 120 percent.
Rabbi Kanievsky continued reading in the Talmud, which described yet another aspect of the days preceding the Messiah.
Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky. “In the days to come, all the
non-fruit bearing trees in israel will bear fruit.” Rabbi Kanievsky
explained, “When the Messiah comes, everyone will repent, and the people
that ‘didn’t bear fruit’ will bear fruit and learn Torah.”
Rabbi Kanievsky seemed to be saying
that in the Messianic era, Christians and Muslims will be a source of
Torah learning – and this phenomenon is appearing as well. Many
movements in Christianity are beginning to seek out their roots in
Torah and Judaism. Hebrew Roots and Bnai Yosef are growing movements
that advocate doing Mitzvot and Torah study.
Both Rabbi Kanievsky and Rabbi
Sternbuch are brilliant Torah scholars whose decisions regarding Torah
law are unquestionably authoritative. When rabbis of this stature agree
that the Messiah is imminent, it is clearly a sign to sit up and take
notice. (and weep)
More than 40 people of prominence have written letters to a judge, requesting mercy for Dennis Hastert, the former Speaker of the House who is awaiting sentencing in a bank fraud and perjury case.
Formally, Hastert is merely facing the music
for illegally-structured cash withdrawals, and for lying to federal
authorities about what the cash was for. But it’s Hastert’s sexual abuse of at least four boys under his care that
has most people a lot more upset. The cash was hush money that Hastert
paid to someone who knew his secret. The statute of limitations has run
out on the child abuse, so Hastert faces at most six month in jail — for
skirting banking regulations, and for his fibs to the FBI.
But even that measly sentence is inhumane, believes Tom DeLay, the former U.S. House Majority Leader, and no stranger to financial shenanigans himself.
In a letter defending Hastert’s character, DeLay referenced not only Hastert’s ill health, but also his faith, writing:
“He is a good man that loves the Lord. He doesn’t deserve what he is going through.”
Four
other congressmen also sent letters asking the court for leniency in
Hastert’s sentencing. They are former California representatives John T. Doolittle and David Dreier, former Connecticut representative Porter Goss, and former Illinois representative Thomas Ewing. All are law-and-order Republicans.
My friend and fellow Patheos bloggerDan Fincke promptly and rightly mocked their concern on his Facebook page:
What has this country come to, what with its political correctness and insistence on actual liberty and justice for all, instead of only for powerful wealthy white Christian men who may abuse all others with impunity! Make America Great Again! Free Dennis Hastert!
The fabulously caustic Mrs. Betty Bowers, a conservative-Christian-impersonating comedian, also reacted to the news in fine style:
As
you will recall, professional Christian scold Mike Huckabee asked the
public to look the other way when it turned out that one of the
Kardashians of Christ — Josh Duggar — is a child molester. Now, Tom
DeLay has asked a judge to do likewise for Dennis Hastert.
Tom
and Mike have just announced that they are forming a new lobbying group
to be called “Politicians Exonerating Deviants Of Sin” (D/B/A “PEDOS”). PEDOS will help stanch the persecution of adults who touch children inappropriately, but only if those adults own Bibles, with the slogan: “Christians are nicer molesters!”
Perfect.
In fairness, we should keep in mind CBS News’ report that
most of the letters of support for Hastert were written six to eight
weeks ago, “before prosecutors had fully detailed the sexual abuse
allegations leveled at Hastert.” That said, credible allegations about
the abuse had been swirling since last year. And even if
all Hastert had done was violate a banking law, it’s still an act of
disturbing hubris for DeLay to say that his friend deserves a milder
sentence because of his ostensible religious piety.
Hastert will
be sentenced on Wednesday. Regardless of the term the judge imposes, his
bigger punishment will be that many of his one-time supporters in
Illinois, where the abuse took place several decades ago, have washed
their hands of him. Case in point: Wheaton College in Wheaton, Ill., his
alma mater, has already removed Hastert’s name from a public-policy center he helped create.
The scene captured by the surveillance camera shows an ultra-Orthodox
man trying to force himself on a young boy in the narrow entrance of an
apartment building.
It happened last month, on Purim, in the Israeli town of Bnei Brak. Within a few hours, the footage was posted on Facebook. Almost immediately, the assailant was identified, and two days later, he was under arrest.
That would not have been the normal course of events 10 years ago, five years ago or even six months ago.
But reporting sexual abuse is no longer as taboo as it once was in the ultra-Orthodox community, and among those who deserve credit for this change is a group of young Israeli crusaders fed up with the long-standing silence about such crimes in their midst.
Their newfound organization is aptly named Lo Tishtok (Thou Shalt Not Be Silent) — a reference to what they say is their unwritten 11th commandment. It was their organization that was first to receive the incriminating footage recorded on the surveillance camera, forwarded by an anonymous resident. “We immediately posted it on our Facebook group,” recounts Tzviki Fleishman, one of the founders of Lo Tishtok, “and asked that if anyone recognized the man in the picture to let us know. It didn’t take much time before someone identified him.”
But that’s when their special challenges began. Among Haredi Jews, Fleishman explains, those who report sexual crimes live in fear of being ostracized for serving as informers and maligning the community. “So we had to intervene with the police to ensure that the person who identified the assailant could maintain his anonymity,” he recounts. “Not only that, but he also refused to step foot inside the police station. So we had to bring an investigator to his house.”
Racheli Roshgold (L), Avigayil Karlinsky, Tzviki Fleishman and Yaakov Matan, the founders of Lo Tishtok, in Jerusalem.
Lo Tishtok began as a Facebook group last October and has since garnered close to 5,000 likes. Initially, it was meant to provide a safe forum for members of the ultra-Orthodox community wanting to hold discussions about what had hitherto been undiscussable. Today, the organization functions more as a support and counseling center for victims of sexual crimes. Currently run on a completely voluntary basis, Lo Tishtok is about to close a deal with a funding organization, its founders say, that would enable it to operate as a full-fledged non-profit.
The Israeli non-profit Tahel has for years provided support to religious victims of sexual abuse, but Lo Tishtok is the only organization in the world to date dedicated exclusively to the ultra-Orthodox community.
The four founders of Lo Tishtok defy common stereotypes linked to ultra-Orthodox Jews — women with large broods of children and men studying in yeshivas. Fleishman, a 26-year-old Chabadnik with one child, is serving belatedly in the Israeli army while pursuing a degree in psychology. Avigayil Karlinsky, a 27-year-old mother of two, just completed a seven-year stint as a programmer in the high-tech industry and is now studying for her bachelor’s in sociology. Racheli Roshgold, a 29-year-old divorced mother of three who was raised in the Ger Hasidic sect, is employed as a gynecological nurse at a religious hospital and as a sex therapist at a private clinic that serves the ultra-Orthodox. A victim of sexual abuse herself, and one not ashamed to speak out about her ordeal as a child, Roshgold is a rarity in her community. Yaakov Matan, a 30-year-old father of three, is employed as a counselor for troubled youth while studying for his degree in psychology.
All four were friends on Facebook when in October of last year, Karlinsky wrote a post that started it all. It was just after the latest wave of Palestinian stabbing attacks had started, and many Israelis were feeling loath to walk the streets. In her widely shared post, Karlinsky compared the vulnerability Israelis in general were feeling those days, men included, to what women experience on a daily basis. “A terrorist sticks a knife in the body,” she wrote. “A rapist sticks a knife in the soul.”
Fleishman had previously spent a few years living in New York, where he had become familiar with the activities of Jewish Community Watch, an organization that works with victims of child sexual abuse. “At the time, this organization had succeeded in ousting the principal of a religious school who had abused children, and all I could think was, wow, these people are really doing something huge,” he recalls. “I knew that when I got back to Israel I wanted to do something like that.” After reading her post, Fleishman reached out to Karlinsky and suggested they create an organization that would combat sex crimes in their own Israeli community. Karlinsky was game.
Their next move was to enlist Roshgold, who had considerable experience with sexual abuse cases in the ultra-Orthodox community through her various jobs. Matan, who had been briefly acquainted with Karlinsky and was quite shaken up by her post, asked to volunteer his services as well.
Since their Facebook page went live, says Fleishman, the group has been approached by “many dozens” of sexual abuse victims through private messages. To date, 10 police complaints have been filed on their behalf.
In some cases, those who reach out to Lo Tishtok are recent victims of abuse. In others, they are adults who have finally found the strength to talk about sexual abuse they suffered as children. The incidence of sexual abuse in the ultra-Orthodox community, says Karlinsky, is not different from elsewhere, from what she and her partners have been able to ascertain. “But what is unique in the Haredi world is that boys are more likely to be victims than girls, and that’s because they’re easier prey. That is to say, they’re more likely to be in close range of potential abusers in the synagogue and yeshiva,” she says, because, with rare exceptions, the assailants are men who serve either as teachers, rabbis or both. These men have much less contact with girls in the ultra-Orthodox world, because girls are generally taught and mentored by women.
At times, the group intervenes to find police investigators sensitive to the particular challenges ultra-Orthodox Jews face when discussing a subject as taboo as sexual abuse. “We had a recent case of a woman who had been raped repeatedly by her brother-in-law, but who had finally gathered the courage to go to the police,” relates Fleishman. “The tone of the policewoman who questioned her, though, completely scared her off. We then approached a Haredi police investigator we knew, and once he was in the picture, this woman was willing to open up.”
Because of her professional experience, Roshgold is the first contact person for callers and is in charge of triage: She decides when a case should be referred to the police, the courts, medical personnel or psychologists. Sometimes, the victims are not seeking treatment or sanctions, but just an attentive ear, in which case she makes herself available to listen — and it can be at any time. “Even if it’s three in the morning, I’m there for them because I know if that’s when the need to speak strikes them, it’s important that I’m there to listen.”
The sexual abuse she suffered as a child, says Roshgold, left her terribly scarred. “But it has also given me the strength to help others,” she says, ”and working with other victims has helped cure the tormented little girl in me.”
Her parents are far from thrilled that this has become her new mission in life, she concedes, but that has not deterred her. “My mother always asks me why I need to talk about these things,” says Roshgold, “and I tell her it’s so that in a generation from now there won’t be any more parents who are embarrassed by daughters talking about such things. And besides that, I tell her, I’m not the one who should be embarrassed. It’s the person who did this to me who should.”
Last week I attended a major
three-day conference of hundreds of Jewish funders, where I participated
in a panel discussion on how philanthropic foundations such as ours
have succeeded in addressing various stigmatized social needs — issues
that other funders seem to avoid. I spoke about our pioneering work in
the field of mental health, and two colleagues representing other
foundations described their groundbreaking work in helping people with
disabilities and people with addictions.
The
room in which our panel discussion took place was situated at the edge
of the hotel grounds, quite a distance from the nerve center of the
conference. I don’t doubt that the choice of location was purely
coincidental, but the symbolism was hard to miss. Unsavory topics tend
to hover on the fringes of Jewish philanthropy’s collective
consciousness — perhaps because donors are loath to acknowledge that
Jews succumb to the same sordid impulses as do the rest of humanity; or
maybe these issues simply depress them.
In the course of my presentation on our work
in mental health, I elaborated on our recent activities addressing child
sexual abuse within the Jewish community. Statistics point to incidence
rates of 1 in 3 among girls and 1 in 7 among boys.
Just over a year ago, our foundation together with two others launched an organization called ASAP.
Since that time, hundreds of child sexual abuse survivors in the US
have come forward to request our help in accessing therapy, and
thousands are being assisted by local NGOs. Similarly, programs that we
support in Israel are experiencing an exponential increase in demand for
their services. And yet, institutions where children congregate, such
as schools, summer camps, synagogues and youth groups, lack effective
policies to prevent incidents of child sexual abuse.
During that panel discussion’s question and
answer session, while we fielded numerous questions from those in
attendance, there was not one question about child sexual abuse. Despite
all the publicity this issue has received, such as the movie Spotlight, the Penn State scandal and the current allegations against former House Speaker Dennis Hastert, the subject remains taboo.
Our efforts to promote awareness have made
inroads with a handful of prestigious educational networks, whose
administrations now realize that implementing effective child-safety
policies — and soon — is vitally important and is in fact in their own
best interests as well. We hope to support these efforts, monetarily,
professionally and operationally, and to extend them to other
institutions.
Yet our coalition of Jewish funders for this
cause remains small. Interestingly, all of us are haredi. As an active
member of this coalition, I have reached out to highly educated,
progressive, deeply caring donors from across the Jewish spectrum to
partner with us to combat this scourge, but with scant success. This
puzzles me, for child sexual abuse is hardly a theoretical problem; the
children and grandchildren of these very donors are vulnerable. All of
our children are at risk.
How is it, then, that we blithely send our
children to institutions that lack effective safeguards against a widely
recognized danger that causes untold damage to such a huge percentage
of boys and girls everywhere? Why aren’t we speaking up, demanding that
our schools and camps and synagogues implement basic protocols for
preventing further incidents? Could anyone think that we can afford to
remain in denial?
It seems that it will take more time for the
Jewish philanthropic community to realize the extent of the problem. We
must be patient, as this happens every time our foundation identifies
and tackles an unaddressed need. It happened in 2007, when we began
helping haredim in Israel integrate into the workforce, and no one else
was interested. It happened again in 2009, when we began helping victims
of domestic violence start a new life – not a popular cause back then.
In each of these cases, eventually, the broader community caught up.
And the community will certainly catch up with our deep concern for child sexual abuse as well. The only question is, How many more of our children will need to suffer before that happens?
“The
world is a dangerous place to live; not because of the people who are
evil, but because of the people who don't do anything about it.”— Albert Einstein
Albert Einstein is, of course, remembered as one
of the greatest physicists of all time. But this Jewish scientist also
had a prolific love of music, politics, and writing, and a profoundly
deep love for Israel.
Einstein was born on March 14, 1879, in the German city of Ulm. As a
young child he moved to Munich with his family—Jewish parents Hermann and Pauline Einstein.
Hermann was a salesman and engineer, moving the family to found a
company that manufactured electric equipment utilizing direct current,
the unidirectional flow of electric charge.
Clearly, an appreciation for the sciences ran in the family. Young
Albert attended advanced classes in primary and secondary school,
building models and mechanical apparatuses for fun in his spare time.
At the age of 10, Einstein met Max Talmud, a Jewish medical student who introduced the future Nobel laureate to a variety of science, math and philosophy texts.
He kept kosher at age 12
Young Einstein went through an observant phase
at 12, even though his parents were secular Ashkenazi German Jews. He
didn’t stay interested in Judaism long enough to have a bar mitzvah
though. A Jewish medical student and family friend — named, ironically
enough, Max Talmud — introduced the creative boy to popular science
books, which Einstein saw as contradicting religious teachings. At age twelve he
discovered geometry (the study of points, lines, and surfaces) and was
taken by its clear and certain proofs.Einstein developed an appreciation of music at an early age. His
mother played the piano reasonably well and wanted her son to learn the violin, not only to instill in him a love of music but also to help him assimilate into German culture. According to conductor Leon Botstein, Einstein is said to have begun playing when he was 5, although he did not enjoy it at that age.[106]
When he turned 13 he discovered the violin sonatas of Mozart,
whereupon "Einstein fell in love" with Mozart's music and studied music
more willingly. He taught himself to play without "ever practicing
systematically", he said, deciding that "love is a better teacher than a
sense of duty."[106] At age 17, he was heard by a school examiner in Aarau as he played Beethoven's violin sonatas,
the examiner stating afterward that his playing was "remarkable and
revealing of 'great insight'." What struck the examiner, writes
Botstein, was that Einstein "displayed a deep love of the music, a
quality that was and remains in short supply. Music possessed an unusual
meaning for this student."[106]
Music took on a pivotal and permanent role in Einstein's life from
that period on. Although the idea of becoming a professional himself was
not on his mind at any time, among those with whom Einstein played chamber music
were a few professionals, and he performed for private audiences and
friends. Chamber music had also become a regular part of his social life
while living in Bern, Zürich, and Berlin, where he played with Max
Planck and his son, among others. He is sometimes erroneously credited
as the editor of the 1937 edition of the Köchel catalogue of Mozart's work; that edition was actually prepared by Alfred Einstein,[citation needed] who may have been a distant relation.[107][108]
In 1931, while engaged in research at the California Institute of
Technology, he visited the Zoellner family conservatory in Los Angeles,
where he played some of Beethoven and Mozart's works with members of the
Zoellner Quartet.[109][110] Near the end of his life, when the young Juilliard Quartet
visited him in Princeton, he played his violin with them, and the
quartet was "impressed by Einstein's level of coordination and
intonation."[106]
As a teenager, Einstein moved with his family once more, first to
Milan, then Pavia in northern Italy. Once the family settled in Pavia,
Einstein returned to Munich to finish his secondary studies.
At 16, Einstein was accepted to the Aargau Cantonal School in Aarau,
Switzerland, then a year later began studies at ETH Zurich to earn a
four-year degree in mathematics and physics teaching.
During this period Einstein met his future wife, Mileva Maric. Maric was also studying under the math and physics teaching program. The couple had a child, daughter Lieserl, in 1902, who was either adopted or died of scarlet fever.
In 1903, Einstein married Mileva. Over the next few years the pair
had two sons, but the couple divorced in 1919. During that time,
Einstein worked on his theory of general relativity, prompting his
summation that light from various stars would bend with the sun’s
gravity.
In 1921, he was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics for his work on the photoelectric effect.
Over the next few years, Einstein traveled extensively, making a
much-heralded first trip to New York City in 1921. He traveled through
Asia and then-Palestine, the only trip he would make to Israel.
He said at the time, “I consider this the greatest day of my life.
Before, I have always found something to regret in the Jewish soul, and
that is the forgetfulness of its own people. Today, I have been made
happy by the sight of the Jewish people learning to recognize themselves
and to make themselves recognized as a force in the world.”
Einstein remarried shortly after his divorce from Mileva, to Elsa Lowenthal.
The Einsteins stayed in the US following a trip in 1933, choosing not
to return to a Germany becoming swept up in Hitler-furor.
The physicist wrote to a friend at the time: “For me the most
beautiful thing is to be in contact with a few fine Jews—a few millennia
of a civilized past do mean something after all.” In a separate letter
he wrote, “In my whole life I have never felt so Jewish as now.”
Einstein became associated with the Manhattan Project in 1939, an
elite group of scientists organized to develop an atomic weapon. It
would become a source or regret for Einstein in later years, though he
still felt vindicated in making a move to urge President Roosevelt to take action.
“I made one great mistake in my life — when I signed the letter to
President Roosevelt recommending that atom bombs be made; but there was
some justification — the danger that the Germans would make them,” he
reportedly told a friend later in life.
In 1940, Einstein officially became an American citizen. He also
joined the NAACP at Princeton and campaigned for equal rights for the
nation’s African American community.
Einstein passed away on April 18, 1955, at the age of 76, after suffering a rupture of an aortic aneurysm.
In the last days of his life, the iconic scientist was working on an
address commemorating Israel’s seventh anniversary, meant for broadcast
to the American people. Einstein carried the draft pages of the speech
with him to the hospital to undergo surgery for the rupture, but died
before he was able to publicly give his address.
In the draft pages, Einstein wrote, “International policies for the
Middle East should be dominated by efforts to secure peace for
Israel…this would conform with the universal ideals of peace and
brotherhood which have been the most significant contribution of the
people of Israel in its long history.”
Famous quotes from Einstein:
“We must enhance the light, not fight the darkness.”
“Tragedy is the difference between what is and what could have been.”
“We can’t solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them.”
“Not everything that counts can be counted, and not everything that can be counted counts.”
“Everyone is a genius. But if you judge a fish on its ability to
climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid.”
“Learn from yesterday, live for today, hope for tomorrow. The important thing is not to stop questioning.”
“A man should look for what is, and not for what he thinks should be.”
"The American ultra-Orthodox and yeshiva community must wake up!"
Every Friday night, I help run a “Carlebach” service in Beit Shemesh.
It’s a unique service that brings together Jews from all backgrounds to
pray, sing and dance on a weekly basis. While closing up the synagogue
this past Friday night, a Hasidic man in his early thirties who was at
this service for the first time approached me and introduced himself.
“Before you were elected to the Knesset, I was in Kollel (religious
seminary for married men), and could not support my growing family,” he
began. “So I went to work. But I felt like a second-class citizen when I
did so, and was made to feel that way by those around me who were still
in Kollel. It got so bad that when I saw someone who knew me walking
by the place where I worked, I would hide so they would not see me
working.”
I began telling him how bad I felt for him, but he cut me off.
“Don’t worry, it all changed when you came into office. The moment
you changed the government’s policies and cut the stipends, and it was
no longer financially worthwhile to stay in learning instead of working,
massive numbers of Kollel guys began working. This made it acceptable
in our community to work, and I no longer felt like a second-class
citizen and I did not have to hide any longer.”
He said that despite the protests against the stipend cuts from many
in the ultra-Orthodox community, he and many others supported our
effort. He also agreed that working to support your family with dignity
is not only consistent with being a Talmudic scholar and fervently
religious, but is actually the ideal.
My new Hasidic friend then said that while he was thankful he had a
job, it was not not the type of job he wanted. He blamed this on his
inability to speak English, and was frustrated that many religious
schools in Israel don’t teach English. “Why didn’t they teach us
English? What could possibly be wrong with English?”
I told him that he was correct, and that was why my political
party, Yesh Atid, cut into the funding of schools that did not teach
English, and pushed to introduce English instruction in all schools.
I said that I needed to start walking home, and he asked if he could join me to ask one last question.
“Those young men with the knitted kippot and untucked white shirts
who were in that service just now — are any of them IDF soldiers?”
I told him that many are active soldiers, and that two or three of them were home from their first week of basic training.
“Unbelievable,” he replied. “They have it all. The way they danced
and prayed, they are clearly very spiritual and religious. They are
serving the country. And they, no doubt, have a general education.
They
have all that, while half of my cousins who were presented with a life
of Torah-only are no longer religious. Had they known that an option of
balance was available, they would still be religious.”
I told him that many in Israel are aware of the problem, and
reassured him that we are committed to correcting it — and that this was
among the reasons I entered politics in the first place.
This remarkable conversation reminded me to tune out the propaganda
and rhetoric coming from the ultra-Orthodox media and its political
leadership, and to keep on working at the important task at hand.
The American ultra-Orthodox and yeshiva community must wake up and
recognize that this Hasid was not an aberration. He is a part of the
silent majority whose voices have been stifled but are crying for
help. We must not fight them; but help them. This is what will ensure
the continuity of Judaism for generations to come.
Rabbi Dov Lipman served in the Israeli Knesset (2013-2015) with
the Yesh Atid party, the first American born MK in 30 years. He holds
rabbinic ordination from Ner Israel Rabbinical College and a Masters
Degree in Education from Johns Hopkins University and currently serves
as Director of Public Diplomacy in the vice chairman’s office of the
World Zionist Organization.